logo
pagesback-cover
182
Reddit meter
all mentions

Seeing Like a State

464 pages, 1999

economics & politics

economics & politics

987 books
history

history

999 books
Takeaways
Description
Big ideas for the improvement of human life have been tried throughout history and have gone terribly awry. Centrally managed plans for social organization misfire because they impose a vision that does violence to the complex interdependencies that are not—and cannot—be fully understood. In addition, the success of designs for social organization depends upon the recognition that local, practical knowledge is as important as formal, epistemic knowledge.
The Danger of Over-Simplification

In Seeing Like a State, James C. Scott warns us about the dangers of oversimplifying complex systems. He argues that governments and other large organizations often try to make things 'legible' or easy to manage, but in doing so, they can destroy the very things that make them work. So, next time you're tempted to simplify a complex problem, remember to consider all its intricacies.

The Importance of Local Knowledge

Scott emphasizes the importance of local knowledge in his book. He suggests that top-down approaches often fail because they ignore the wisdom and experience of the people on the ground. So, if you're in a leadership position, make sure to listen to those who are directly involved in the work. They might have insights that you would otherwise miss.

The Failure of High Modernism

High modernism, a belief in the power of science and technology to improve human life, is critiqued in Seeing Like a State. Scott shows us that this approach often leads to disastrous results, as it ignores the complexity of human societies. So, before you jump on the latest tech trend, take a moment to think about its potential impacts on society.

The Power of Nature

In his book, Scott reminds us of the power of nature and the dangers of trying to control it. He uses examples from agriculture and forestry to show how attempts to impose order on nature often backfire. So, next time you're planning a project, remember to respect the natural world and work with it, not against it.

The Role of the State

Seeing Like a State gives us a new perspective on the role of the state in society. Scott argues that the state often tries to impose order and control, but this can lead to unforeseen consequences. So, when you're thinking about government policies, remember to consider their potential impacts on the ground.

Quotes 3

Scott's book is a powerful critique of the high-modernist, authoritarian state and its non-democratic goals, making it a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the nature and evolution of the modern state.

Francis FukuyamaFrancis Fukuyama - Political scientist, author

Scott's 'Seeing Like a State' is a profound exploration of the processes that have shaped our modern world. It's a book that challenges us to think differently about the way we live and the structures that govern us.

Robert D. KaplanRobert D. Kaplan - Author, foreign correspondent

Scott's work is a compelling examination of the state's desire for legibility and control, and the often disastrous consequences of its attempts to impose order on the complex realities of human society.

Michael IgnatieffMichael Ignatieff - Politician, author
Francis FukuyamaRobert D. KaplanMichael Ignatieff

Recommendations

2
Nat Eliason

Nat Eliason

entrepreneurmarketerauthor
Scott Young

Scott Young

journalistauthor